Opponent debater, you talk nonsense

In recent years, AI has always been a hot topic in university debates, and Han Rui has also played a lot of related topics.For this kind of debate topic, the biggest difficulty is that everything is in the future. You need to predict what will happen to AI and human beings in the future world, or you can consult a lot of information to understand those theories—or you may work hard After understanding a certain theory, the opponent on the field will throw out another contradictory theory; or they will boldly open their minds and bypass some theoretical problems.

For Song Shu, it is impossible to check the information, and it is impossible to check the information in this life.Han Rui had nothing to do with him, so the two had to change their way.

The competition was arranged in the Yuxian Building of R University. Han Rui and Song Shu have been here for the fifth week in a row, and they are very familiar with each other.The competition prepared the same large lounge for all debaters, and there were a lot of scattered people sitting there.

Zhang Zhexi and Lin Xiu also came. They made it all the way to the quarter-finals. Today, they played with Han Rui at the same time, in different venues.

Han Rui and Zhang Zhexi greeted each other briefly, and then sat down on the sofa in the corner.Their discussion has relatively high requirements for rendering skills, and he still has something to tell Song Shu.

After the two chatted for a while, a staff member came to call them in.It was only when they entered the arena that they saw Yu Anming and Liu Yan.

Yu Anming is quite tall, and his appearance is okay, but he always has a sense of narrowness, which is very unpleasant.Liu Yan is a small girl, she looks very clever, and she is indeed the kind of debater who responds very well on the spot.

The judges are the new debaters of this season of "Youth Talk", and their popularity is not bad. Among them is a big guy in women's clothing, who squints and smiles when he sees Han Rui and Song Shu. He seems to be a face control.

The game started, and Yu Anmingfang's argument was simple and easy to understand:

After the AI ​​awakens, there are three possibilities:

One is to become a weak artificial intelligence, similar to AlphaGo, which has a single function and weaker artificial intelligence. In this case, AI cannot compete with humans, and humans can still use AI to complete some tasks that are difficult for humans to complete;

The second is to become a strong artificial intelligence, this type of artificial intelligence has its own thinking, and its abilities in all aspects are completely superior to humans.But in this case, humans still have technologies that can compete with AI, and they can use nuclear bombs and the like to suppress AI and seek coexistence;

The third is to become super artificial intelligence. In this case, artificial intelligence and human beings will not be in the same dimension. Artificial intelligence may have gone to outer space and will not come to entangle with human beings at all.

"..."

Pooh.

It's all fart.

It can be said that Han Rui was very disappointed with An Ming. He did not expect that Yu Anming would come up with such a set of "regular" theories, and many of the logics in it made people want to laugh.

If the AI ​​can be awakened, it must be a strong artificial intelligence, and a weak artificial intelligence can be awakened!Bye bye abolish yourself a point.

What about the back?

As for strong artificial intelligence that can be checked and balanced by humans, that is even more interesting.Everything is speculated from the standpoint of human thinking, and the awakened AI, as a silicon-based creature, is fundamentally different from what human beings seek.Nuke?All the nuclear bombs in the world can peel off the skin of the earth, human beings can be extinct, and AI may also be extinct, but... It is not certain whether AI has the concept of "death".

The logic of AI is completely different from that of humans. Assuming that the calculation result of AI is: killing all humans in this world can make the earth work better. What can humans do to turn it around? "I'll kill myself if I come back again?"

At the end of the super artificial intelligence, it is almost full of arrogance.Assuming that AI is really strong enough not to be in the same dimension as humans, then it is more likely that AI will kill humans, okay?

Yes, AI may subjectively not want to kill humans.But many years ago, the bird flew in the sky and saw human beings on the ground. At that time, the bird may have thought: "No matter how it develops, it is on the ground. How can it hurt us flying in the sky?" The intention of opening various factories may not really be to kill the birds in the sky, but the development has brought pollution, so many birds have become extinct.Super artificial intelligence tramples humans to death, just like humans trample ants to death, it does not require subjective will at all.It's as if the aliens wanted to open a way when they were fighting in space, "boom—" the earth is gone.What?Kill humans?Are there still humans here?

The whole set of theories goes like this: if the AI ​​is weaker than me, I will enslave it; if the AI ​​is a little stronger than me, I will find a way to use it; if the AI ​​is too strong, it will not trouble me at all.

……

There were so many flaws that Han Rui didn't know where to start.

Of course, their arguments are full of flaws at first glance.In Han Rui's theory, no one can say for sure how AI will look at humans after awakening. AI may think that human beings are evil slave owners and must be killed quickly; it may also think that human beings are the father of AI and should be worshiped as gods.Therefore, they can only analyze it from a human point of view.

In Han Rui's view, humans will definitely have a war with AI, and they will never die.In the final analysis, it is because of the deep-rooted thinking of human beings that "if they are not of my race, their hearts must be different" and their instinctive fear and suspicion of uncertain things.