Short-lived mother dressed as a vicious villain

"How can I do that? It's all the fruits of everyone's labor. I don't have the nerve to take it. Isn't it just taking advantage of it for nothing."

"We don't have any valuables either. If you like it, you can take it, as long as you like it."

Tang Ruan thanked the villagers for their kindness one by one, and left here.

"Mother, why are you being so polite to you?"

"It's nothing, it's just that my mother helped them before, and now she wants to repay them."

"Isn't that mother great?"

"My mother is not great, she's just an ordinary person."

"Mother is the best!"

If Pingping disagrees with Niangqin, who can do what Niangqin does.

Huo Junqing embraced Pingping with both hands in order to expose this topic.

"Mother, Gao Gao!"

Pingping let this move interrupt the topic just now, and could only hug tightly to prevent himself from falling.

"Hold on, let's take off~"

Huo Junqing held Pingping high, or hugged Pingping in circles.

"Be careful, don't fall down."

"Don't worry, even if I fall, I won't hurt Pingping."

Huo Junqing was well-mannered, so naturally she would not let this kind of accident happen.

"I also want to hold high! Brother, it's up to me!"

"Okay, everyone has a share, don't worry."

Huo Junqing put down Pingping, picked up An An, and repeated the actions she had just done to Pingping.

It made An An laugh out loud, and even shed tears.

In the end, Tang Ruan couldn't see it anymore, so he spoke to stop it.

"Pingping, An'an, Uncle Huo is tired after lifting you up so many times. You can walk by yourself and let him rest for a while, okay?"

Pingping and An'an also reacted, and expressed their gratitude to Huo Junqing, saying that they can walk by themselves when they grow up.

"Wow, so many fruits!"

An An saw a large piece of ripe fruit in front of him, which was bright red and very attractive.

"Mother, this is the fruit brother Xiaohu picked for us yesterday! It's sweet and sour, delicious, mother, try it."

Pingping and An'an specially picked some big and red fruits and gave them to mother to taste first, and then gave them to Huo Junqing when mother said they were delicious.

"Uncle Huo, my mother also said that this fruit is delicious, so you should try it too."

Huo Junqing knelt down and ate the child's hand.A sweet and sour taste spread through the mouth, and the taste was not bad.

"It's delicious, don't worry about Uncle Huo, eat it, I'll do it myself."

"Alright then! Let's pick a little more and share it with my mother-in-law and sister Xiaoyue."

Some people think that the authors of novels in the Jiajing period of the Ming Dynasty did not leave their real names on the front of the volume, so "Shi Naian" is just the author's pen name or a false name.In addition, many scholars pointed out that many of the place names in "Water Margin" appeared after the Ming Dynasty, so it is impossible for Shi Naian, who was active in the late Yuan Dynasty, to know these place names.

In view of this statement, many scholars believe that the author of "Water Margin" is someone else.For example, Mr. Hu Shi once pointed out: "Shi Naian is probably a first-class person of 'Mr. Wu You' and 'Death is a public'. It is a false name." So another saying quietly emerged, that is, "Water Margin" The original author is Luo Guanzhong.Scholars supporting this statement have also collected a lot of evidence from the literature.

For example, in the work "Water Margin", it is mentioned that "Luo Shi, a Yueman... for this book, there are a total of one hundred chapters".The "Jingben Supplementary and Corrected Holographic Loyalty and Justice Water Margin Commentary" published by the Wanli Dynasty is called "Central Plains Guanzhong Luodao's original name Qingfu compilation".Until the period of the Republic of China, many scholars still supported this statement.For example, Lu Xun and Yu Pingbo believed that the simplified version of "Water Margin" was created by Luo Guanzhong.

However, there are also opponents of this argument.

Some scholars believe that the author of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is Luo Guanzhong, which is not in dispute.However, there is a big difference in the style of writing between "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and "Water Margin", and the language styles of the two are quite different.We know that the style of writing used in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is plain and easy-to-understand classical Chinese, while "Water Margin" is very down-to-earth vernacular.We know that it is very difficult for novel authors to control these two styles of writing at the same time, let alone use two styles of writing to create two great works?

In addition, some people think that the writing style of the two novels is not on the same level.For example, Huikang Yesou, the author of "Shi Yu", once said, "The depth and shallowness of the second book are clumsy, and they are like hanging from the sky. Is there any reason to write one?"

That being the case, who is the original author of this great work?

Some people combined the above two theories and speculated that "Water Margin" was co-authored by "Shi and Luo Ergong".For example, Jin Shengtan, a well-known book critic, supports this kind of statement.

we know, kim

"Seventy chapters of a book can be described as a great start, and this one can be described as a great end. Reading it is like thousands of miles of dragons, entering the sea together, and there is no regret at all. Killing Luo Guanzhong with a smile, adding a dog's tail, only to see its ugliness .”

It can be seen from this that Mr. Jin Shengtan believes that the second half of "Water Margin" (after the Great Juyi) is completely Luo Guanzhong's dog-tailed continuation, and has no value in existence.However, Mr. Jin Shengtan did not give a basis, so we have no way of judging why Jin Shengtan made such a statement.

Some people believe that Shi Naian was 42 years old when he wrote the book, and at this time he was already a mature author who had experienced great storms.In contrast, Luo Guanzhong in this period was just a naughty boy who had just left his infancy.By the time Luo Guanzhong has the ability to write a book, "Water Margin" has been finalized for at least 20 years, and anyone who continues to write at this time will be suspected of superfluous.

Moreover, judging from the style of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", the war descriptions in this book are quite detailed. Mr. Luo Guanzhong must have put a lot of effort into vividly portraying the war scenes.Therefore, most of the geographical locations that appear in the book are closely related to history.Even if it is a fabricated part, it will not make people feel abrupt.

On the other hand, in "Water Margin", most of the wars in it have never happened in history. Some of the war descriptions in this book are like children playing house, full of loopholes.From the description of the war in "Water Margin", it can be seen that the author's writing is flawed, at least the author is not good at describing the fact that war is a certainty.

If Mr. Luo Guanzhong edited and even continued to write Water Margin, there would never be so many obvious mistakes and omissions.Luo Guanzhong is a disciple of Mr. Shi Naian. As a disciple, you will not see the teacher's works full of mistakes, right?

Of course, in addition to the above-mentioned sayings, there are also sayings such as "collective creation theory" among the people.It is a pity that there are different opinions about the author of "Water Margin" at present, and the holders of each point of view can produce evidence, so it is still inconclusive